Jane Doe IV testifies
 
  • One member of the prosecution team is Craig Barlow, with the Office of the Utah Attorney General. Barlow, the chief director of the Children's Justice Division, has an indirect tie to the twin cities of Hildale and Colorado City where approximately 6,000 followers of prophet Warren Jeffs live.

    Barlow's grandfather's brother was John Y. Barlow, the first mayor of Colorado City. Barlow said his grandfather was never part of the community.

  • Walter F. "Wally" Bugden Jr. has been a criminal trial attorney for 30 years and an adjunct law professor at the University Of Utah College Of Law for 5 years, and has tried over 200 criminal jury trials, according to his Web site. Since 2000, he won acquittals in 20 jury trials with charges ranging from manslaughter, negligent homicide, forcible sexual abuse, rape, and aggravated sexual abuse of a child to assault and drunken driving.

    Not only is Bugden known for his acquittal rate, but for his unusual bow ties and glasses that he favors.

    Bugden also is known to wear mismatched socks. When asked about wearing the mismatched socks, Bugden replied, "That's just me."

  • On Wednesday, Warren Jeffs was transported to court via a state helicopter. After the helicopter landed, Jeffs, wearing the green and white stripped prison clothes with a bulletproof vest and shackles, was escorted into the courthouse by two Washington County Sheriff's Office bailiffs.

    During the final jury selection process Thursday morning, 5th District Judge James L. Shumate told those in the qualified jury pool that they had all passed the "for cause" reason for dismissal and were now up for pre-emptory challenges. Shumate explained to the jurors that they could now be excused for the color of their blouse or their haircut. Shumate also said that he had sat in front of hundreds of jurors and had never seen a jury make a mistake. "The jury verdict always made sense," Shumate said.

  • Shumate also told the potential jurors that the United States has the finest justice system on the face of the planet and that only about a dozen countries have a jury system.

    "The wealth of experience a jury brings to make a decision is without price," he said.

  • Since the first day Warren Jeffs has been in court, a regular visitor at the courthouse is a St. George resident named Mary. Retired, Mary has been coming up to the courthouse to watch the activity and said she has learned so much and said it has been interesting to follow the case to see how the system works.

    "I'm out here living the news," Mary said. "I always liked journalism."

    Mary said it's also exciting to be at the courthouse and watch all the goings on because, as she said, "the world has come to St. George."

  • Thursday afternoon, partway through Jane Doe IV testimony, a strange song started playing in the courtroom.

    The source of the music was Ryan Shaum's cell phone. While cell phones are normally allowed in the courthouse, cell phones along with recorders and transmitting devices are banned for the public and media during the Warren Jeffs jury trial. Shaum, the lead prosecutor at the Washington County Attorney's Office, is in one of the groups who are allowed to bring a cell phone into the courthouse, but all phones are to be off or on vibrate during court proceedings. Shaum's cell phone was removed from the courtroom by a bailiff.

  • By court order, Warren Jeffs will still be able to have standard visitation and telephone privileges. Because Jeffs is in court all day, the order states that the jail will need to make special accommodation to permit standard visitation to either occur on weeknights or on the weekends. Additionally, Jeffs shall be entitled to use the telephone and have the same telephone privileges during the trial that he had before the commencement of the trial.

  • During opening statements, Washington County Attorney Brock Belnap said that something the girls of the FLDS community are told is to "keep sweet," which Belnap explained was to suppress their desires and project an image that the person is peaceful, happy and content.

  • Defense attorney Tara Isaacson gave a brief summary during opening arguments about the FLDS culture, which includes arranged marriages and polygamy. Isaacson said during the course of the trial, members of the FLDS religion will tell their stories and talk about their marriage and belief systems. Isaacson said it is different from media portrayals.

    - The Spectrum & Daily News

ST. GEORGE - Jane Doe IV said she knew nothing about sexual intercourse, how babies were made or male anatomy when she was married.

The first time Doe's husband took her against her will, she was so upset afterward and felt so dirty that she couldn't even go to her mother, who lived in the same house, who Doe considered her best friend and confidant, she said.

Instead, Doe retreated to a bathroom were she swallowed a bottle of ibuprofen and Tylenol, she said.

"I wanted to die," Doe tearfully testified. "I didn't want to deal with (her husband), the prophet, Warren (Jeffs), Fred (Jessop) or my mother. I was so hurt by them."

The events leading up to and including Doe's marriage at age 14 to her 19-year-old first cousin in April 2001 are still so painful to Doe that during her testimony Friday morning, Doe broke down sobbing and asked Judge James L. Shumate for a short break to compose herself.

Doe was the first witness called in the state's case against Warren Steed Jeffs, 51, on two charges of rape as an accomplice for his alleged role in arranging the marriage between the young girl and her cousin.

Doe talked about growing up in the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, whose principle doctrines are plural and arranged marriage where sex was not talked about and how a woman grew up believing that the only way to heaven was through her "priesthood head," whom upon marriage, was the woman's husband.

The girl knew nothing about sex and said the only thing she knew was that once she started her menstrual cycle she was told she was "now ready to have children."

Married at the age of 14, Doe talked about how she pleaded with Rulon Jeffs, Warren's father who was the prophet of the church at the time. Warren Jeffs was the first counselor and the next in the chain of command under his father.

Third in line was Fred Jessop.

Doe testified that when she found out she was to be married, she spoke to Jessop about the upcoming marriage and said although she did not want to defy the prophet, felt she was too young to marry.

Once she found out it was her cousin she was to marry, a man she called a "bully" in the preliminary hearing, Doe went to Rulon Jeffs and spoke to him.

"He put his hand on my head and told me to follow my heart and to keep sweet," Doe said tearfully. "I was so grateful." But minutes later, Warren Jeffs reportedly told Doe that "her heart was in the wrong place and this (the marriage) is what the prophet directed her to do."

Denying the prophet's word, Doe said, is unthinkable in the religion, which also doesn't talk about sexual intercourse but calls it man-wife relationships.

During the first full day of testimony, a defense attorney objected to Doe's recounting the story about Rulon Jeffs, resulting in a recess.

Judge James L. Shumate ruled that the statement was not hearsay and that Doe could relate what Rulon Jeffs, who is deceased, said to her.

Doe was questioned by Craig Barlow, who is on the prosecution team about how she could have left the Hildale community when she found out she was to be wed, but Doe said there were no options for her.

Instead, in complete despair, she had to prepare for a wedding and while making the wedding dress, Doe said she kept thinking she was getting ready for death.

Doe was reportedly married by Warren Jeffs in a hotel in Caliente, Nev., along with her half sisters - Ruby and Annie Jessop - who were married to Haven Barlow and Jerry Barlow, respectively.

Doe said Ruby's husband was in his 20s and Annie's was in his 30s when the girls were wed.

Doe said she didn't know at the time what the word "rape" meant and cried and pleaded with her husband the first time he took her against her will.

During the latter part of Friday afternoon, audio tapes of Home Economics classes by Jeffs were played.

One tape talked about how girls are to keep the "bars up" and have resistance when it comes to men until one man is chosen for her and then it's "bars down" and that each morning, a wife shall rejoice in his will.

"A woman obeys a man as far as a man obeys the prophet," Jeffs says on the tape.

"Keeping sweet" and a woman giving herself mind, body and soul were also frequently on the tapes played.

After a long week, after listening to the tapes for almost an hour, several people, including Jeffs himself, nodded off although earlier, he appeared to be taking notes as his tapes were played.

Barlow said the prosecution and defense teams had concurred not to play the remaining hour of taped teachings of Jeffs and recessed early for the weekend.

Tara Isaacson, one of Jeffs' defense attorneys, spoke during the opening statements about if a rape even occurred and if so, was Jeffs knowledgeable about the alleged rape.

Isaacson said during opening statements that Doe never told Jeffs she was being raped, and Doe testified that when she talked to Jeffs, she told him that her husband was touching her in places that she didn't want to be touched and was doing things she didn't like.

Jeffs' reply, according to Doe, was that she was to repent and give herself to her husband mind, body and soul.
 
TheSpectrum.com
Originally published September 15, 2007
 
Back